It’s all over but the shouting.
The Journal Star reports that the City has notified Gary Matthews that they are terminating the redevelopment agreement for the Hotel Pere Marquette and surrounding properties.
In short, the three-page letter states the city is within its rights to pull out of the agreement because it is after Dec. 31, 2010 — the date at which the city could unilaterally withdraw under the terms of the deal if certain benchmarks were not met — and that there still are significant details missing on the financing Matthews’ business, EM Properties, was required to obtain. Indeed, it states that what has been provided thus far is “nothing close to what the city could prudently accept” as evidence. […] Though city lawyers believe the letter sent to EM Properties is adequate notice to terminate the agreement, City Council members will be asked to formally ratify the decision in a vote at their Sept. 13 meeting to confirm they agree with the move.
Letter Terminating the Wonderful Development
And so dies the vaunted Wonderful Development — a project that was so time-critical that it had to be approved practically overnight three years ago without any public input and as little notice as legally possible; a project that was going to be constructed “immediately” according to Matthews in May 2010; a project, the financing of which the Council was assured by Mr. Matthews was all in place over a year ago; a project Mr. Matthews was so confident about that he loudly and publicly blew off Councilman Gary Sandberg’s questions, saying “Just vote no, councilman”; a project that was going to cost the City of Peoria taxpayers up to $37 million, most of which was going to go into the pockets of Mr. Matthews and the owners of Big Al’s; a project that was going to relocate Big Al’s to a piece of property immediately adjacent to a day care facility; a project that ultimately fell apart like a house of cards.
City leaders will no doubt bemoan the cancellation of this project and say it’s a sad day for Peoria. And there may indeed be some unfortunate outcomes. The fate of the Pere Marquette would seem to be in question, for instance. But the losses that would have resulted had the project come to fruition would have been far worse. The City simply can’t afford the debt service on up to $37 million in bonds. No matter what they tell you, that project was never going to pay for itself. Their predicted occupancy rates and revenues were about as likely to come to pass as the Cubs winning the World Series.
On a positive note, I just want to express my appreciation to Mayor Ardis and City Manager Patrick Urich for finally pulling the plug on this project. You just know there was no small amount of pressure placed on the City to contribute even more toward making this project a reality, but to their credit, they said enough is enough. They didn’t let Matthews come back to the well a third time looking for more concessions and/or funding.
My hope is that, out of this abject failure a better project will arise: one that is privately funded and likely to succeed; a truly wonderful development.
UPDATE: I contacted Randy Ray to find out the disposition of the Franklin Street lot. Here’s his response: “The contract with Main Street Trust and Al’s for the Franklin lot terminated by its own terms because closing did not occur by July 31.” So, in other words, Big Al’s will not be moving, and the City retains ownership of the lot adjacent to the bus depot.