My friend David wrote this insightful comment on Bill’s blog tonight about rail service in Peoria:
I think people need an education about the importance of railroads – even in the 21st century.
Fact: Several U. S. air carriers are in Chapter 11 yet ALL U. S. freight railroads are solvent.
Fact: The US is still the largest manufacturing nation in the world and big, heavy stuff needs to be shipped short, medium and long distances. Locally, grain processors like ADM, Aventine and MGP are HIGHLY dependent on local railroads for their existence. Keystone Steel & Wire, which recently emerged from Chapter 11 and has regained lost customers, is also highly dependent on local railroads for receving raw materials and shipment of product nationwide. Caterpillar tractors are big and heavy and all of these shipped to export markets go by rail to West, Gulf and East Coast ports.
Fact: Metro Peoria is served by TEN railroads. There are few other cities in this country with that status.
Fact: Peoria is competing with the likes of Rochelle, Illinois, which is quite proactive in developing rail-served industrial sites – even building new track to access these areas. The city owns the railroad and connects with two Class 1’s (BNSF and Union Pacific), thus allowing for rate competition.
Fact: Rochelle is served by its own shortline and two Class 1’s; while Peoria-Pekin’s Tazewell & Peoria RR connects with NINE others – BNSF, Canadian National, Central Illinois RR (for now) Illinois & Midland, Iowa Interstate, Keokuk Junction, Norfolk Southern, TP&W and Union Pacific. Peoria leaders seem to forget this, and towns like Rochelle attract major industrial developments, and the good-paying jobs that go with them.
Peoria is a bit small for commuter trains. Rail freight service is what matters.
DPJ
As usual, David’s comments are worth their own post — can’t stand to see them buried in the comments section. As for his last point — that Peoria is a bit small for commuter trains — I’m afraid I have to agree. I would love nothing more than to see commuter rail in Peoria, but I don’t think it’s feasible at this time.
In an article just published today, I read that the state of Arizona is considering statewide commuter rail, but the reason is to relieve highway congestion because their population is projected to double or even triple in the next twenty years. Illinois’ population trend doesn’t look so promising, and Peoria’s population in particular appears to be stagnant or falling. Couple that with the six to eight lanes we have through town on the interstate now, and I don’t foresee any traffic congestion for years to come.