Comprehensive Plan survey results are in

Peoria LogoRoss Black, Assistant Planning Director for the City of Peoria, has released the results of the Comprehensive Plan online survey. You can read the summary results here (PDF file); more details will be released in the near future.

Take a look at them and tell me what you think. Here are some things I thought were interesting or notable:

  • The one-to-ten scale is inverted — lower numbers indicate higher satisfaction or importance and vice versa.
  • They’re still saying that lower scores indicate that something is “not important.” I think that’s misleading, as I’ve explained in this earlier post.
  • Survey-takers’ satisfaction with Peoria as a place to live is decidedly middling: 4.2. In other words, “so-so.”
  • Not surprising was that the top two districts to respond to the survey were the fifth and second districts (29% and 21%, respectively).
  • Very surprising was how many people took the survey who don’t even live in Peoria (18%) — they were actually the third highest group! Gee, thanks for the input, interlopers. I suppose one could make the argument that these are people who have businesses or rental properties in the city, but who personally live outside the city. If so, then the high percentage is even more disturbing.
  • Lowest district representation: first (5%). This is not surprising. The first district includes predominantly lower-income residents, many of whom presumably cannot afford computers and internet access, and even if they can, don’t have the time to spend filling out surveys. There are also a lot of renters who presumably would not have as much interest in the city’s comprehensive planning process. Many may also just simply feel disenfranchised — like nobody cares about their opinions anyway.
  • 93% of respondents were white, 5% were black, 1% were Asian, 1% were “other,” and less than 1% were Native American. According to the 2000 census, 69.3% of Peorians were white, 24.8% were black, 2.3% were Asian, less than 1% were “American Indian.”
  • The higher the income, the more people responded. 80% of respondents had a household income of over $50,000. 20% of respondents had household income less than $50,000. Median household income in 1999, according to the census: $36,397.
  • 35% of respondents would “like to live within walking distance from downtown and the riverfront.” That’s a little more than one out of every three respondents — a significant number.
  • The number one item under Public Health and Human Services: “Provide youth services that guide children toward good behavior.” Wow. Apparently it takes a government to raise a child. When I was a kid, we had parents to guide children toward good behavior. Now we need “youth services” provided by the city.

Your turn. What are your thoughts on the results?

7 thoughts on “Comprehensive Plan survey results are in”

  1. Lower income residents don’t have the time? Must be a factoid from Bizarro world.

  2. Nontimendum: If you’re, for example, a single parent, you work a lot of hours to put food on the table and provide daycare for your child while you’re at work, which ain’t cheap. The time you’re home you want to spend with your child, not filling out a survey for the city. If you’re single with not much education, you may have a low-paying job or two that require a lot of time, leaving you little time to fill out a survey.

    If you’re thinking of the stereotypical multi-generational welfare recipient who sits at home all day collecting government handouts, such people are probably not terribly interested in what the city looks like so long as they keep getting free money.

    And if you’re thinking about drug dealers, well, they’re not going to complain about Peoria being a difficult place to do business.

  3. You put forth three stereotypes (that’s all they really are), including mine. I’ll stick with my one, which I believe takes in more of the south end populace these days than do your others.

  4. “35% of respondents would “like to live within walking distance from downtown and the riverfront.” That’s a little more than one out of every three respondents — a significant number.”

    Not significant enough I guess. This was presented on WCBU this morning as “the majority of Peorians don’t want to live within walking ditance of downtown.”

  5. Services in order of importance: #2 Education. Level of satisfaction with current services: Education is last. Under the education header: Increase student achievement to meet or exceed academic standards.

    Is cutting 45 minutes out of the school day the best way to achieve or improve these goals?

    Remember, we are doing what is best for the children…..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.