Death of downtown retail no cause for celebration

Seeing the Sears block demolished is a dream come true for many, and it is exciting that we’ll be getting a Peoria history museum. But at the same time, it feels a bit like the graveside service for downtown retail in Peoria. Downtown shopping became ill and infirm in the 1970s and ’80s and finally died in 1998 when Sears moved to Northwoods; now we’re just burying the body.

I applaud the city’s efforts to lure tourists through the upgraded riverfront and this new museum. But downtown isn’t going to be really vital until you get large retail stores down there again. It’s the one huge piece of downtown revitalization that’s missing, and every consultant Peoria has hired has said the same thing.

But instead, the city gives incentives for large retailers to locate on the fringe of town while it works overtime to put money-losers like the Riverplex and Gateway Building downtown. When is someone — anyone — going to start working on a plan to draw new retail to downtown?

The Heart of Peoria Commission seems like a logical group to take on this issue, but I’m afraid they’d spend a whole year just “appreciating the complexity of the task.”

But seriously, why is nothing being done about this? Has Peoria just given up?

Sears Block History

I thought it was cool that WHOI took the time to look at the history of the Sears block. I didn’t see any other stations do this. Here’ s the report as it appears on their website:

Sears Block Secrets
Oct. 7, 2005 – Peoria
by Brock Spencer

Nearly 200-years of Peoria history can be found on the spot where the Sears block now stands, and come Monday demolition crews will begin digging-up the old to make room for a whole new era. A look into the history books reveals that the Sears block has some secrets to share.

It was a time when farming was a way of life for American settlers. But even before the Sears block was a thought, historians say it was a treasured place in time.

Dr. Peter Couri with the Peoria Historical Society said, “When the first American settlers came in 1819 they settled right here. We know the Fulton Family and the Eaton Family where farming right on this spot.”

Around this family farm grew the city we now call Peoria.

Then as the 1850’s hit, the area became a hot spot for more businesses.

Couri said, “You had a hotel next to a carriage shop, you would have a pottery next to a fine china shop, and just businesses galore.”

One of the most famous businesses that existed on this block was actually run by Wyatt Earp and his brother in the 1870’s.

“It was actually a house of prostitution and they were arrested in the 1870’s and kicked out of Peoria to start their illustrious career in the Wild West,” said Couri.

Over the next 90 years, buildings remained similar in architecture.

That’s until the entire block at Water and Main Street was demolished to build the Sears Store in the 1960’s.

Couri said, “It was a wonderful way to keep retail business down in Peoria. There was Sears, there was Carson-Perry-Scott, and Bergners all formed in a triangle of retail.”

But as shopping centers started making the headlines, the Sears Store moved away from downtown and into Northwoods Mall in 1998.

Still, the history of this block is not finished.

“It was a really wonderful development. We hate to see it go, but progress comes on,” said Couri.

And soon the block will be open again for business with plenty of new history to write.

The Sears Company actually started business in Peoria in 1928, but didn’t move to the riverfront Sears block until 1965. The new museum and Caterpillar Visitor Center are expected to be completed by 2009.

I just love articles on Peoria history like this — so much so that I’ll forgive Mr. Spencer for misspelling Carson-Pirie-Scott. On the news, they actually showed quite a few historical photos of the block — none pre-Sears, however. But there were a couple that allowed you to see Carson’s and Bergner’s in the background.

For those of you unfamiliar with Peoria history, the old Bergner’s has been razed and replaced with the ugly boondoggle “One Technology Plaza.” The old Carson’s (formerly Block & Kuhl) was converted to a bank building — Jefferson Bank originally, now Bank One.

Cards heading to NLCS

In the wee hours of the morning, the Cardinals won their series against the San Diego Padres.  Not a big accomplishment, considering AAA-Memphis could have probably beaten the NL West Division winners who ended up a whopping two games over .500.  The real work begins this week as the Cardinals take on either Houston or Atlanta.
 
Interestingly, none of the three St. Louis games were on network television.  And the last one started after 10 p.m. central time.  So even St. Louis residents who can watch the Cardinals games on KPLR had to stay up until after 1 a.m. to see the outcome of the game.  Please.  I understand that it was a west coast game, but even there the game didn’t start until after 8 p.m.  That’s a late start no matter how you look at it. 
 
I hope the Cardinals get some better coverage and time slots in the NLCS. 

Restaurant Review: Bud’s Aged Steaks

To celebrate our eleventh anniversary last night, my wife and I took in a movie and then went to dinner at Bud’s Aged Steaks, formerly VOP (Vonachen’s Old Place).  We made reservations, fortunately, because it was a busy night.  Even though we got there at 7:30 (a late dinner in my book), there was still a 30- to 35-minute wait for a table if you didn’t have a reservation.  We got right in, of course.
 
The first things we noted were the changes to the decor.  Gone are the train depot benches and large scale in the lobby.  Now there are some apholstered chairs around a coffee table with a copy of Wine Spectator magazine to peruse while you wait.  Also gone are the wood-fired pizza oven and pizza bar near the hostess stand.  Instead, large wine racks partition the dining area from the hostess stand and waiting area.  Also, directly across from the hostess stand, there is a small refrigerator case with various cuts of meat on display.  The large historical photos that VOP had on the walls are still there.  However, the O-guage train and track above the kitchen entrance are gone.  The walls have new wood paneling on the lower half of the wall, with the upper half painted taupe, and lots of track lighting has been added, making for a warm atmosphere.  They use real linen tablecloths and napkins, but they put white paper on top of the tablecloth, I guess to protect it (which makes one wonder why they use linen tablecloths at all).
 
The wait staff was dressed professionally in black pants and white shirts with white aprons.  Our waiter was very courteous and attentive.  Our drinks, water for my wife and iced tea ($1.79) for me, were kept filled.  My wife ordered the filet ($24.95) and I ordered the New York Strip ($27.95).  The steaks came with a house salad in a red wine vinagrette dressing, choice of potato (we both got baked), and some freshly baked bread with real butter.  The bread was the same as Vonachen’s used to serve — warm and not too crusty.  The salad dressing was delicious, and the salad sizes were reasonable.  The salad included a couple different kinds of lettuce, small slices of red onion, thin slices of radish and provolone cheese, some diced tomatoes, one large chunk each of carrot and celery.  It’s pretty hard to screw up a baked potato, but for the record, the baked potatoes were very good and just the right size.  The steaks were tender and juicy and mine was cooked to perfection (medium).  My wife ordered hers medium-rare and found that it was a little redder than she prefers.  But that was probably because of the thickness of the filet.  Both our steaks were very flavorable.
 
My wife and I aren’t wine drinkers, which makes this review a bit incomplete since Bud’s is very proud of their wine selection.  So, for what it’s worth, the couple at the table next to us raved about the bottle of wine they had, telling the waiter it had excellent body.
 
We got a complimentary slice of cheesecake since it was our anniversary.  It had a graham-cracker crust and was served with a few red raspberries on top and two forks.  It was very creamy and delicious.
 
Overall, my take is that it’s a nice upscale restaurant, but I would have preferred it stay the old VOP.  We have plenty of upscale places to go in Peoria (Jim’s Steakhouse, Jim’s Bistro, Carnegie’s, Lindsay’s, Jill’s, Seven, French Toast, Red Zin, F. Scott’s, etc., etc.) but not so many local (non-chain) casual or family places.  I’m not sure why they felt the need to get into the oversaturated upscale market, but that’s their choice.  If you have the money, it’s not a bad place to get a steak.  Our bill, including that wonderful 10% Peoria tax but not including the tip, came to $60.16.  At those prices, we won’t be able to afford going there again anytime soon.  With the tip, that was almost a week’s worth of groceries.  Worth it for our anniversary and maybe a few other special occasions, but that’s it.

Baseball has too many playoffs now

So, Major League Baseball added the wildcard ten years or so ago and, with it, another round of playoffs — the Division Series.  Supposedly, this was to make the postseason more exciting and improve television ratings. 
 
However, just try watching or listening to the Division Series in Peoria.  Tonight, the White Sox completed a three-game sweep of the world-champion Boston Red Sox (the best second-place team in baseball last year).  But you didn’t see or hear it here.  It was nowhere to be found — unless you have expanded cable and can get ESPN2.  Alternatively, you could listen to a very staticy AM signal out of Chicago (ESPN AM 1000).  Following that game, the Angels went up two games to one against the Yankees.  And again, it was not on network television or any local radio station.
 
So, what good is the Division Series?  I know you could tell me to just break down and buy cable, but that’s missing the point.  What’s ESPN2’s viewership compared to Fox Network’s viewership?  Don’t you think if Division Series play was a big ratings draw that it would have been on network TV?  The fact that they bury it on ESPN2 and have such poor radio coverage tells me that they view it as a throw-away series.  And since MLB agreed to this broadcast arrangement, I guess they see it the same way.
 
So I say, throw it away.  In fact, just go back to two divisions in each league and get rid of the idiotic wildcard.  Make the Championship Series a best-of-5 series again and put it on network television along with the World Series.  If MLB doesn’t care about the Division Series, why should we?

The Electric Company

I’ve been hearing AmerenCILCO commercials on WMBD radio all the time lately telling me that electric rates are going to go up dramatically in 2007. I finally checked out their website, www.post2006.com, just to see what it was all about. Here’s the summary from their home page:

Ameren’s Illinois utilities are part of a competitive marketplace for electricity that began in late 1997, when the Illinois General Assembly joined a national movement and passed legislation to create an open and competitive retail marketplace for electricity.

Separate electric delivery rates were established under that legislation, and the regulated utility companies were encouraged to spin off or sell their power generating assets to expand the market for buying and selling energy. Today, selling electricity has become a competitive business. Illinois consumers have the right to choose a power supplier other than the utility. For those customers who choose not to select an alternative supplier, Ameren’s Illinois utility companies will continue to provide power at their actual cost, without mark-up.

Now, Ameren’s Illinois utilities own almost no generation. With the end of the transition into competition coming on January 1, 2007, we need to buy electricity in the open wholesale market to serve our customers.

This all sounds great, but what competition do we have in Peoria? “Illinois consumers have the right to choose a power supplier other than the utility,” the website says. How? What other power suppliers? By “Illinois,” do they mean Chicago? With the deregulation of telephone companies, I’ve had no shortage of marketing mail and phone calls asking me to switch carriers, yet with the power competition I haven’t heard anything.

If there’s no competition, it looks like we’ll be over a barrel when electricity rates go up 25-30%, as predicted. And when that happens, the Howerters of Canton won’t look so crazy for disconnecting from the power grid completely.

The city can’t do everything

I was catching up on Bill’s blog today and read his post, “Gettin’ while the gettin’s good.” In it, he advocates two things: (1) he would like to see city-wide WiFi (short for “wireless fidelity,” a wireless local area network that would be used for internet access), and (2) the city should at least start it, if not run it — it “should be considered infrastructure, and hence a legitimate government fuction,” according to his post.

I agree with his first point. City-wide WiFi would be a plus for the MedTech district and be one more feather in Peoria’s cap for attracting high-tech business to our fair city. But to say the city government should run it is a mistake. I’m seeing a trend here… First he’s for the water company buyout, now city-run WiFi… Pretty soon we’ll have the city owning phone service (wired and cell), electric/gas service, and cable television! Then maybe they could take over gas stations and grocery stores, too. The city that does it all!

Internet service is a profitable industry. Wouldn’t it make more sense to have private companies provide WiFi service to Peoria? In fact, isn’t that the very kind of business we want to attract to the MedTech district? Considering they wouldn’t have to string cable to everyone’s house, the overhead should be considerably lower for such a business, making it easier for them enter the marketplace. Then we’d have a company that buys land, pays taxes (property and sales), and employs people — and we won’t have city resources tied up in something that should be privately run.

I understand the increasing role the internet plays in our business and personal lives, but I don’t think it’s an essential service right up there with police and fire protection. And it’s profitable enough that it doesn’t need to be subsidized by the local government.

Cardinals are on the air!

I was down in St. Louis this past Saturday and had the pleasure of seeing the Cardinals collect their 99th win of the season.  It was a perfect day for baseball:  sunny, 78 degrees, cool breeze, a Pujols two-run homer in the first followed by a Larry Walker solo homer.  It doesn’t get any better than that! 
 
Sunday, I listened to the Cardinals win game #100 this season, the first time since the mid-1940s that they’ve had back-to-back 100-win seasons. 
 
Then, today I found out the best news of all:  WMBD is actually going to preempt Rush Limbaugh to air the Cardinals game at noon.  Hallelujah! 

Peoria 1977

I have here Peoria’s City Directory from 1977 (don’t ask me why), and I thought you might enjoy some of the descriptions and predictions of Peoria from 28 years ago:

Population: 134,000
Area: 40 square miles
Parks: 7,000 acres
Airport: City is served by Ozark Air Lines, Continental Airlines, and chartered service by Byerly Aviation Company.
“By number of employees, Peoria’s five major industries are the Caterpillar Tractor Co., Pabst Brewing Co., Westinghouse Air Brake Co., Keystone Consolidated Industries Inc., and Hiram Walker & Sons, Inc.

“Peoria Water Co., in 1976 completed a $3.7 million addition to its Illinois River station that will increase water production capacity by 10 million gallons per day.

“Illinois Bell Telephone Co., in late 1977, will be installing a traffic service position system (T.S.P.S.) which is an electronic computer like system for handling long distance calls.”

And downtown was a hot topic then like it is today:

Vision of Future Peoria in 1977

Peoria is looking to the future with a comprehensive plan to redevelop the Central Business District. The distinguished Washington (D. C.) architect and urban designer, Angelos C. Demetriou, AIA, was hired to create a downtown plan for Peoria and do a feasibility study of its long cherished dream of a Civic Center. The Demetriou Plan for downtown Peoria revolves around two key concepts: the mini-mall to spark retail shopping and the development of the riverfront to attract a 24-hour a day lifestyle in the Central Business District.

The Downtown Plan, developed by a team of consultants led by Angelos Demetriou, is tailored for Peoria. The document begins by building on the existing strengths largely provided by the over $70 million in downtown investment which occurred over the past 15 years. Integrated with the results of those 15 years of accomplishment are new projects which will broaden downtown’s base and which will make it possible to reach new potential for growth identified in the Plan.

The Plan outlines several major elements of change for the downtown.

They include: Housing about 2,550 units downtown; a civic center complex serving three important functions: a convention-oriented exposition hall with 20,000 sq. ft., an auditorium for the performing arts, and a sports arena-assembly hall. Also, new hotels to support the civic center; an enclosed shopping mall to strengthen the retail core; new offices for government, large firms and general occupancy; extensive beautification and improvement of riverfront; and convention parking which is so essential to downtown revitalization.

Considerable activity is underway for implementing the Plan.

The $6.4 million Peoria School of Medicine was opened in 1976 and its medical students are now undergoing training at the various hospital complexes located in the Peoria area.

Downtown received another boost when Cohen Furniture Company completed a major renovation of the “flagship” store at Harrison and Adams.

Final construction drawings are being prepared for the open air plaza on Fulton, between Jefferson and Adams, and renovation of the existing Jefferson Building in downtown Peoria. The plaza would connect the civic center activities in the “superblock” with the enclosed shopping mall between Bergner’s and Sears. The City has not yet proposed a financial plan to pay for this improvement. However, with a feasible financial plan, the project could move very quickly.

The county and city are negotiating for a new city-county administration building. The building would be located at Hamilton, between Adams and Jefferson, across from the Courthouse Plaza. The city has allocated revenue sharing funds toward the project and acquiring the property for the development.

The Peoria Downtown Development Council has been working closely with the City of Peoria and the U. S. Postal Service in the location of a regional Post Office in Peoria. The building will be constructed on about 10 acres of large blighted property on the southern edge of downtown. Also, the city and county have been discussing the issue of building a new jail. The site has not been finalized, however, it will be a common shared facility of the county and city.

These public projects will offer important contributions to downtown and help created the needed environment for major private investments to occur.

Well, that certainly sounds exciting, doesn’t it! It’s not quite the same as DPZ’s Heart of Peoria Plan, but there are a few overlaps: they both agree that retail is vital to downtown (Demetriou recommended building a mini-mall downtown; DPZ said the Shoppes at Grand Prairie should have been built downtown), that there should be more housing options downtown so people can live there, and that your downtown should “attract a 24-hour a day lifestyle.”

I’m actually quite amazed at how much of Demetriou’s plan was realized. The civic center was the biggest thing, of course. Unfortunately, the biggest departure from this plan is the retail aspect. In 1977 there were still several department stores downtown: Bergners, Sears, Sparr, Szolds, and Woolworth. Not only did Demetriou’s mini-mall idea never materialize, but the existing retail stores disappeared as well.

This does answer one question I’ve had for a long time: what was the purpose of Fulton Plaza? It was to connect the Civic Center to the retail shopping “superblock.” Now that Bergners has been replaced with One Technology Parking Deck and the other stores are gone, one wonders why we don’t tear the plaza out and make Fulton a through street again.

In 2033, when we look back at the Heart of Peoria Plan and Vision 2020, I wonder which things will have been implemented and which ones will have fallen by the wayside. I have a feeling there still won’t be any retail downtown, and we’ll probably have hired a new consultant to tell us pretty much the same thing the last two have told us….

Hurricane Judgement?

I was listening to WMBD this morning before work, and Greg and Dan were grappling with a question I’ve heard several times now about Hurricane Katrina and now Rita. I’ll paraphrase it here: “Are these hurricanes God’s judgement on the sinfulness of the people living/partying there?” That’s a pretty heady question to tackle on the radio between Apple Blossom Farm commercials and and CEFCU Traffic One updates.

But I’ll take a stab in the blogosphere at answering this question from a conservative Christian viewpoint: I don’t think these hurricanes are specific judgements from God.

First of all, judgements from God are generally supernatural, not natural disasters. If New Orleans were to be destroyed by fire and brimstone falling from the sky, or if an angel of death were to smite the firstborn of every family there, then I’d say it was God’s judgement. But I don’t believe God was the direct causitive force behind the hurricane.

Secondly, something similar happened in Jesus’s time. In Luke 13:1-5, it says this:

Now on the same occasion there were some present who reported to Him about the Galileans whose blood Pilate had mixed with their sacrifices. And Jesus said to them, “Do you suppose that these Galileans were greater sinners than all other Galileans because they suffered this fate? I tell you, no, but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish. Or do you suppose that those eighteen on whom the tower in Siloam fell and killed them were worse culprits than all the men who live in Jerusalem? I tell you, no, but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish.”

Isn’t that interesting? I think it’s completely in keeping with this scripture to imagine this conversation with Jesus today. It would go something like this:

Someone reports to Jesus about the people who were killed in the hurricane down in New Orleans, and Jesus says, “Do you suppose that these Americans were greater sinners than all other Americans because they suffered this fate? I tell you, no, but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish. Or do you suppose that those 3,000 on whom the World Trade Center fell and killed them were worse culprits than all the men who live in New York? I tell you, no, but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish.”

Jesus asks that penetrating question that people have been asking for centuries whenever disaster strikes: Did this happen because those people were worse sinners than everyone else? Was this divine vengeance on these people?

And Jesus, who often doesn’t answer questions directly, gives us a direct answer to this one: “I tell you, no.” I love the simplicity of that answer. “No!” By implication, “No, it’s not divine vengeance, and no, they’re not worse sinners than you. You’re just as sinful as they are.” And he follows that up with the ominous words, “but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish.”

Jesus is exposing a judgemental attitude here. He’s saying, in essence, “stop judging those people just because they met a tragic end. Take a look at yourselves! You’re not any better than they are. You are the ones who need to repent.” It kind of reminds me of that other verse that is so often quoted, “Judge not, lest ye be judged. For in the way you judge, you will be judged; and by your standard of measure, it will be measured to you.” (Matt. 7:1-2)

So, I don’t think the hurricanes are a specific judgement of God on New Orleans or even the United States in general. But, the hurricanes do remind us of our own mortality and that life is short. That should give us pause to consider what our own fate will be when we die: is there life after death? Is there a God to whom I’m accountable? Am I ready to meet him?